A growing dispute over prediction markets has reached New York courts, with state regulators accusing two major crypto-linked platforms of running unlicensed gambling services under the guise of financial trading.
New York Moves Against Crypto Prediction Platforms Over Gambling Claims
New York Attorney General Letitia James has launched legal action against Coinbase Financial Markets and Gemini Titan, alleging both firms are operating illegal gambling schemes through their prediction market products.
The complaint argues that users are effectively betting on real-world outcomes such as sports results, entertainment events and elections without the required state licences.
James says the platforms should have obtained approval from the New York State Gaming Commission before offering these services.
Instead, they allegedly allowed trading activity that mirrors casino-style wagering while avoiding regulatory oversight.
Are Prediction Markets Just Another Form Of Gambling
At the centre of the case is the question of whether prediction contracts are financial instruments or simply bets in disguise.
The state argues that users have no control over outcomes, making the activity equivalent to gambling under New York law.
James said,
“Gambling by another name is still gambling, and it is not exempt from regulation under our state laws and Constitution.”
The complaint also highlights age restrictions.
While New York requires participants in mobile sports betting to be at least 21, both platforms reportedly allowed users aged 18 and above to take part.
Heavy Penalties Sought Including Profit Forfeiture And Fines
The Attorney General is seeking wide-ranging penalties, including the return of profits made through the alleged unlawful activity, civil fines equal to three times those profits, and compensation for affected customers.
The state is also pushing for restrictions that would prevent the companies from accepting wagers from anyone under 21 and from advertising on college campuses.
Officials argue the platforms also bypassed tax obligations that apply to licensed gambling operators, reducing funds that would otherwise support public education, youth programmes and gambling addiction services.
Coinbase Pushes Back As Gemini Stays Silent
Coinbase has rejected the claims and vowed to continue defending its position.
Chief Legal Officer Paul Grewal said the company intends to pursue federal oversight of prediction markets.
“Coinbase will continue to fight for the federal oversight of these markets that Congress intended.”
Gemini, founded by Cameron and Tyler Winklevoss, did not immediately respond to the lawsuit.
Both firms only entered the prediction market space in mid-December, rolling out services that are now available across all 50 US states.
State Vs Federal Power Struggle Over Prediction Markets
The lawsuit is unfolding amid a broader jurisdictional battle between state regulators and federal authorities.
The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) has argued it holds exclusive authority over prediction markets, warning that state-level rules create conflicting obligations for companies operating nationally.
The CFTC recently sued several states, including Arizona, Connecticut and Illinois, in an effort to block local attempts to regulate the sector.
Its chair, Michael Selig, warned that inconsistent oversight could harm consumers rather than protect them.
Courts And Regulators Split As Industry Gains Momentum
Court rulings have so far been mixed.
A federal appeals court in Philadelphia recently sided with prediction market operator Kalshi, ruling that New Jersey regulators could not block its contracts.
However, Nevada has secured temporary injunctions preventing both Kalshi and Coinbase from operating within the state.
Kalshi has also taken legal action against New York regulators in a separate federal case, while its dispute remains unresolved.
Lawmakers Warn Of Insider Trading Risks And Political Influence
On Capitol Hill, at least eight bills have been introduced since January targeting prediction markets, with concerns focusing on insider trading and market manipulation.
Attention intensified after reports that a user made around $400,000 from a prediction tied to political developments in Venezuela, alongside trading activity linked to US military strikes on Iran.
Senator Jeff Merkley described the sector as “a real danger to our democracy and ripe for exploitation by public officials with insider information,” while Senator Todd Young urged Congress to act despite political sensitivities.
Some lawmakers have also pointed to links between industry platforms and political figures.
Donald Trump Jr. is an adviser to both Polymarket and Kalshi, and a Trump-linked media group has announced plans for its own prediction platform, Truth Predict.
The White House has denied any conflict of interest, saying insider trading rules already apply and must be enforced across all markets.