According to Jin10, analyst Conor Sen said he did not think Fed Governor Christopher Waller would persuade his colleagues to raise rates by 50 basis points in December, but Waller appeared to be trying to secure 25-basis-point hikes in both December and January. Nick Timiraos, described as a “Fed whisperer,” reposted Sen’s comment and said one interpretation was that Waller was fighting a losing battle to achieve a 50-basis-point move; another was that he was emphasizing the broader policy consequences of dismantling the Fed’s communications system. The two interpretations are not necessarily mutually exclusive.
The broader question extends beyond December’s policy strategy. The Fed could stop publishing its dot plot, omit interest-rate projections from its Summary of Economic Projections, stop holding news conferences, and remove references to the balance of risks from policy statements. That would broadly resemble how the Fed operated in the Greenspan era before 1999. In that scenario, words could not substitute for action because the Fed would no longer guide market expectations through language; it would have to act. Waller’s remarks imply that if the Federal Open Market Committee abandons the communication tools it built over more than 20 years, a 25-basis-point hike followed by silence about the future policy path would not be enough.