According to Sina Finance, Citigroup retained Rob Smolen with improved terms after he had planned to join Barclays, highlighting a practice known as “gazumping” in the contest for top trading talent. Smolen returned to Citigroup as head of equity trading for Europe, the Middle East and Africa; he had previously led its global exotic derivatives trading.
In recent months, traders have moved to rival banks and hedge funds, while some employers have made last-minute offers to keep them. Matthias Schwartz, a former Bank of America senior credit trader and founder of Career Capital One, said traders who receive retention offers either generate substantial revenue or are critical to a trading desk’s stability. Spokespeople for Citigroup and Barclays declined to comment.
The retention was a significant win for Citigroup’s global equity trading head, Fat Belbashir, whose equity derivatives team had lost traders to BNP Paribas, Qube Quantitative Strategies and Barclays. In October, Millennium Management recruited Luca Vallituitti, Citigroup’s global head of exotic derivatives and index forwards trading.
Barclays’ global markets head, Adil Khan, also takes part in retention efforts, sometimes flying overnight to New York. Smolen’s planned arrival would have strengthened the equity team led by Scott McDavid. The division’s third-quarter revenue rose 47% year over year, its best performance since at least 2009.
People familiar with the matter said JPMorgan and Bank of America also retained traders who had been preparing to leave this year. Some banks are adopting hedge fund practices, including non-compete agreements, termination penalties and compensation clawbacks. Contracts for some senior Jefferies traders require payment of a penalty, amounting to a large portion of first-year compensation, if they do not join; sources said the candidate’s current employer typically pays it.
Recruiters may coach candidates on declining counteroffers or keep in touch to remind them of their commitments and the prospects of a new role. Schwartz said banks may also raise pay for remaining team members after a key trader leaves. Traders who stay face the risk that their negotiated pay increase could shrink substantially the following year.